Yes, that would be cool! But it's never going to happen. No sex. No drugs. No rock and roll. It would have to be on the Hallmark channel or something.
But just for fun, I decided to put a cast together. Keep in mind, this is just for kicks.
Michael Rosenbaum as me. I'm the main character after all!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ee718/ee718b2ef34b2020bac8851c473deee92cf8d81e" alt=""
Rosenbaum could be pensive as Lex Luthor on Smallville, but also funny in his voice portrayal of The Flash in the Justice League cartoon. Most importantly, he can manage the right hair style.
Besides, hollywood makes everyone better looking than they are in real life.
Challenges
Rosenbaum will have to act slightly more goofy to be an accurate portrayal of myself. Plus, he'll have to come off a little more naive, since I feel that way about many things whether dealing with religion or life.
Jensen Ackles from Smallville as Elder Childs.
Why I chose him
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9fa45/9fa45c45d6f0fa85f715c8743cc1f18e789c0446" alt=""
Challenges
Ackles will need to dye his hair blond, and he'll have to be more wholesome than his tough guy character on Supernatural. Still, I think he could pull off the role.
Vin Diesel as Elder Dowling
Why I chose him
They've got the same hair style and similar stern expressions. They are not guys you want to mess with.
Challenges
Vin is a little old to play Dowling. He'll also have to pull back on the intimidation factor a bit. The essence of Elder Dowling is "I'm a nice guy, but don't make me angry."
Sally Fields as Sister Ruth.
Why I chose her
Plus, Sally is now about the age of the Sister Ruth I remember.
Challenges
Nun (or should I say none?). Sally Field can fly! She can do anything!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/157d7/157d73ae93b12f1469820701cf6c5f7cf593d476" alt=""
Seth Green as Elder Kelsey.
Why I chose him
The red hair. Plus, he could pull off the famous "donut incident." He can be both serious and funny, a must for anyone portraying Elder Kelsey
Challenges
Green is too old and much too short for the role. We'll have to use poetic license here.
WWE star Jack Swagger as Elder Bailey
Why I chose him
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f5b5d/f5b5d2768c4a0f11048de216ff1fdc33ff6789b5" alt=""
Challenges
Swagger will have to come across as likable, and I hope he has some acting skill.
There are a lot more characters I could have picked from, but this list took a LONG time to create. One notable exception is Elder Luke, who is a big character in the story. After racking my brain, I just could not come up with an actor who could fulfill the stoic role.
Anyway, I got a kick out of making this list. I hope you get a kick out of it too. Let's hope James Cameron is watching....